Is There a Future for Socialism?

First entry in an exchange with Jacobin, by Asad Haider and Salar Mohan­desi: “Is there a Future for Social­ism?

We all won­dered, as we watched Back to the Future, how alter­na­tive futures could change the whole uni­verse while Marty McFly stayed the same. Those movies amounted to a Rea­gan­ite phi­los­o­phy of his­tory: the short-cir­cuit between the Fifties and the Eight­ies which con­verts every con­tin­gent encoun­ter into one reac­tionary loop, cen­tered on the white man who secretly invents rock n’ roll, seduces his mother, and con­quers the space-time con­tin­uum.

Against this phi­los­o­phy, we say there’s no point in his­tor­i­cal coun­ter­fac­tu­als. His­tory is that which is the case; while we start with the premise that his­tory could have hap­pened dif­fer­ently, we can’t escape the fact that the van­tage point of our analy­sis is his­tory that hap­pened the way it did. The twen­ti­eth cen­tury as we know it might not have taken place; but our world is con­sti­tuted by its explo­sions, tragic and ecsta­tic.

This is why we’re pleased to enter into an exchange with Jacobin, whose logo recalls that we live in the world made by Tou­s­saint L’Ouverture and the Black Jacobins. The rever­ber­a­tions of their con­fronta­tion with the colo­nial­ist uni­ver­sal­ism of the so-called “bour­geois rev­o­lu­tions” would be felt through­out the 19th cen­tury – just as, in 1848, the Jacobin­ism of Blan­qui would be chal­lenged by the growth of work­ing-class neigh­bor­hood clubs.

To talk about the future of social­ism, we’ll have to begin with its past. We’ll have to look at the future that past social­ists pro­jected – a future that was “guar­an­teed” by the lin­ger­ing ide­ol­ogy of the bour­geois rev­o­lu­tion – and mea­sure it care­fully against the real­ity.

Read more…

Be sure to check back at Jacobin for the rest of the dia­logue.

Author of the article

Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.

Please comment with your real name using good manners.

Leave a Reply